🧂 How to decide if your startup needs a full time designer

Hey there. Happy Saturday! Today, I want to share some advices on hiring designers for startups.

A few months back, I watched a startup founder firing their first designer who couldn't handle multiple types of projects. The designer maybe excellent at product UX but completely lost when asked to create brand guidelines or marketing materials.

After six months of mismatched expectations and frustrating deliverables, both parties agreed to part ways. The founder jumped in to work with my studio fractionally right away when I reached out.

This founder's mistake is more common than you'd think. In my 12 years of designing for Silicon Valley startups, I've seen countless founders either hire designers too early, too late, or hire the wrong type of designer entirely.

The truth is, there's no one-size-fits-all answer to "should I hire a full-time designer?" But there is a framework to help you make the right decision.

How to decide if you need a full-time designer

Hiring a full-time designer is a big commitment—and one that early-stage founders often rush into too soon or for the wrong reasons. Design can unlock serious value for your product, your team, and your brand—but only if you hire the right kind of designer at the right time.

Before you post that job listing, ask yourself these 8 questions.

1. What’s your business model?

B2C products typically need strong design earlier than B2B. Consumers judge by first impressions—and you're often fighting for attention in noisy markets like the App Store or social media. B2B can sometimes get away with a scrappier look in the early days.

2. Which industry are you in?

Traditional SaaS, fintech, or enterprise tools require deep UX thinking to reduce complexity. In contrast, Web3 and AI products often demand polished UI to make cutting-edge tech feel accessible and trustworthy.

3. How innovative is your technology?

If you're building something totally new, users may tolerate rough edges—early adopters are more forgiving. But in saturated or competitive markets, great design might be the only way to stand out and gain trust.

4. What kind of design (generalist v.s. specialist) do you need?

Design is not one-size-fits-all. Do you need brand identity, marketing design, or product UX? A product designer may not know how to craft a compelling brand story. A brand designer may struggle with interaction design. Know the difference—and hire accordingly. You might be looking for a unicorn—someone who does product, brand, research, and motion—but they’re rare. Know what your priority is, and hire someone who’s great at that one thing.

5. What stage is your team/product at now?

Design needs change with product maturity. Early MVPs benefit more from speed and feedback loops than visual polish. Growth-stage products, on the other hand, need strong UX and brand design to convert, retain, and scale.

The typical ratio is one designer per 10–12 engineers. If you’ve got 3–5 engineers, a full-time designer might be underutilized. Consider a fractional designer or agency until your team and velocity grow.

6.What’s your design velocity?

Look at your roadmap. Are you shipping features weekly, or quarterly? Do you need pitch decks, landing pages, and emails designed alongside your product? The answer will help you determine whether there’s enough work to justify a full-time hire.

7. Do you have someone to prioritize design work?

Even great designers need direction. If you don’t have a PM or founder who understands how to integrate design into product strategy, things will stall.

Designers need context, feedback, and prioritization. If you’re too stretched or don’t have a culture that values design, a contractor or design lead might be a better interim solution.

8. What’s the return you expect from this hire?

Don’t just hire a designer to “make things look good.” Ask: will they help increase conversion? Improve retention? Strengthen your pitch to investors? Design should drive outcomes—not just aesthetics.

Here's the real kicker: hiring the wrong designer is worse than hiring no designer at all.

I've seen startups hire brand designers expecting them to fix their product experience, or bring on UX designers when they really needed someone to create marketing materials.

The result? Frustrated founders, confused designers, and wasted resources.

If you're an indie founder bootstrapping your startup, there are more important roles to hire first. Focus on getting engineers, sales, or operations people who can directly impact revenue. Design can wait.

If you're VC-backed with budget, consider these alternatives before committing to a full-time hire:

• For branding and website design: Hire consultants to do it right once, then move on. These are typically one-time projects that don't require ongoing iteration.

• For social media and marketing graphics: A part-time designer or design subscription service will handle your needs without the overhead of a full-time employee.

• For ongoing product UX iterations: This is when you need a full-time product designer. But make sure you have enough product complexity and iteration velocity to keep them busy.

Summary

The decision to hire a full-time designer isn't just about having the budget—it's about timing, team size, product complexity, and understanding exactly what type of design work you need.

Most early-stage startups are better served by targeted design consulting or subscription services that provide senior-level expertise without the commitment and management overhead of a full-time hire.

Ask yourself: Are you hiring a designer because you actually need ongoing design work, or because you think successful startups are "supposed to" have designers?

Ready to get clarity on your design needs? I'm currently taking on 2 more monthly clients (AI startups preferred) to help with brand launches, website design, or UX improvements to boost retention. Let's chat about what type of design investment actually makes sense for your stage and goals.

Share my newsletter

Loving my content so far? I’d appreciate if you can share my newsletter to a friend 🙂